Board of Education Action Meeting: November 19, 2026
by Lisa Haver

(Photo: Lisa Haver)
On September 21 of this year, APPS members emailed the Board of Education, asking that they honor their own by-laws concerning attendance of board members. We reminded them that Board Policy 006.1 states that a board member may attend meetings via electronic communication “only under limited circumstances.” We also reminded them that Policy 006.1 states that board members participating via electronic communication “must be visible on the screen.’ We sent that email because over the past year, some board members have been marked present and allowed to vote on official agenda items despite violating this policy; members of the public often hear a voice with no video, or see a board member only in the first few minutes of the meeting. APPS never received a response. At this November meeting, Board Members Joyce Wilkerson and Cheryl Harper were marked “present” and allowed to vote on all items despite being invisible the entire meeting. At almost every meeting, APPS members raise objections to the board’s violation of the Pennsylvania Sunshine Act. Does the rule of law mean anything to this governing body?
Kristin Luebbert and Deborah Grill contributed to this report.
Teachers Union Issues Alternative Facilities Plan
APPS members stood in solidarity as PFT President Arthur Steinberg reminded the board in his testimony that “everyone is against this plan.” Steinberg asked why neither Watlington nor the board has given a reason for closing schools. Last week, the PFT issued its own alternative facilities plan, one that calls for no school closings. The PFT facilities plan includes specific recommendations for each of the 17 schools. In stark contrast to the district’s plan, the PFT plan cites funding projections and sources, along with a clear timeline for completion of modernization and construction projects. PFT members from Lankenau, Stetson and several other schools testified in favor of the union’s plan. Steinberg notified the board that PFT leadership has asked its members at the closing schools not to participate in the district’s transition committees as the district has not fully informed members of those school communities about the real purpose of those committees. (The district faced similar complaints from members of their appointed facilities committees last year. APPS members asked several times for the district to release all committee reports; we received no response. We can only conclude that there are no committee reports and the district did not incorporate their recommendations into the final Facilities Master Plan.) Steinberg received no reply from Superintendent Tony Watlington Sr. or from any of the board members. They gave no indication that they would consider the plan submitted by the people it often refers to as their “labor partners”. Later in the meeting, community member Lynette Cohen reminded the audience that Mayor Cherelle Parker, who appoints the entire board and has endorsed the district’s facilities plan, will face re-election in 2027 and urged eligible students to register to vote.
Board Considers Creating A New Charter School
Last year the board approved an application for a new charter school, the first since the board was reinstated in 2018. Board members acknowledged the cost to the cash-strapped district but voted for it anyway, with only BM Joyce Wilkerson dissenting. Now the same board that approved closing 17 public schools is considering approving the creation of yet another charter school. The district’s facilities plan makes no mention of the high cost of maintaining charters, most of which consistently perform at rates lower than district schools. In addition, most of the city’s charter schools are under-enrolled. The Charter School Office presentation gave little information other than the proposed charter’s name, address and projected enrollment (the report was not included in either the hard copy or the online post of the meeting agenda). Charter companies have built a powerful patronage system in Philadelphia. At the October action meeting, CASA president Robin Cooper told the board that if they continue to put charter schools before public schools, they should resign from the Board of Education and apply to serve on a charter school board.
Board Spends $11 million to Restore Substitutes
Last year, the board approved a budget which eliminated all building substitutes, the teacher subs who serve every day in the same school. Ignoring the effect that would have on the children, the board made its decision based only on the financial promises made by the Watlington administration. CFO Mike Herbstman testified at the time that the district would save $13 million by eliminating 220 building subs. The move to eliminate building subs came not long after the PFT won its case to make the building subs PFT members. Chalkbeat Philadelphia quoted a statement from parent advocacy group Lift Every Voice, which had fought the building sub eliminations last year: “At this rate, eliminating building substitutes could cost more than if we had kept them.” With neither the board nor the administration admitting its mistake, the board approved an $11 million retroactive contract extension with ESS, the company which supplies the district with substitutes. The board engaged in no deliberations on the item. The administration did not respond to requests from Chalkbeat to comment on the issue. APPS member and former counselor Lynda Rubin has testified at board meetings over the years about children’s need for stability. This board claims to be “for the children” but this is one more example that proves otherwise. The board should restore all building substitutes.
Absent Board Members Vote on Official Items
The board passed all 14 agenda items unanimously, approving $12, 607, 981 in spending. There was no deliberation on any item. Board Members Wilkerson and Harper, neither present in the auditorium or visible on the screen, voted on all items. The board has apparently reached an agreement among themselves to refrain from discussion about action items in public, Board President Reginald Streater refers to this as a more “efficient” way to run the public meetings.
The meeting adjourned at 6:26 PM.
Upcoming Board Meetings
Board Action Meeting: Thursday, December 3, 2026 at 440 N. Broad Street.
Published November 23, 2026
